Quantcast
Free video subscription: Zip Code:
Optional Member Code
Brave New Films
Campaign: Sick for Profit
Posted by David Dayen on October 2nd, 2009
How Alan Grayson Changed The Debate On Health Care

Many of us already knew that Alan Grayson was a fearless champion against the rich and powerful. His notoriety this week for comments about the Republican plan for health care therefore did not come as a shock. His floor speech and his unwillingness to back down afterward have set a new standard for how Democrats deal with Republican hissy fits, where they get all offended by some comment or another and demand an apology and ritual humiliation. Their goal is to control the narrative and put any Democratic use of moral language out of the bounds of acceptable political debate, a standard that doesn’t apply to them.

Grayson DEMOLISHED this tactic. And he did so by continuing to tell the truth and never backing down. And by the end of the week, many were joining him. Yes, they said: why does the GOP have no plan for health care? Why have they allowed thousands to die for a lack of coverage for years without articulating any strategy to deal with the crisis? Why would Republicans try to make an example of Grayson when their members have been using vile language for months, slandering the health care legislation with lies about “death panels” and rationing and people “being put to death by their government,” in the words of Virginia Foxx? How could Republicans think there is no crisis in health care when so many are dying?

In a second, this has become the narrative of the week on health care. And Alan Grayson led the way. He just might lead the Congress to a better bill.

Brave New Films celebrates Alan Grayson’s contribution to the debate with this video.

Let Rep. Grayson know you have his back. And join the I heart Grayson Facebook group. He really deserves the attention he’s getting.

  • docwillis
    With all the loud talk (ussually from the right) of "death panels" and "killing grandma", it's nice to finally give due to the thousands of uninsured people, who are dying because they have no insurance, or they can't get insurance because of pre-existing conditions. Yes, health care needs to be reformed. NOW!
  • Name
    An American Political Hero.

    Hey "texasconservative" why don't you get a life instead of posting to the same comment area 10 times? Bet you are using Medicare and sent your kids to public schools! (The horror - SOCIALIZED EDUCATION!)
  • texasconservative
    It's bothering you isn't it. Not being one of the sheeple on this blog really upsets your preconceived Liberal-nonsense, doesn't it!
    Yes, our socialized school system is a pathetic joke, as witnessed by the lack of cogent arguments posted, and your right of the top of that list!
  • Name
    texasconservative, you are an idiot or a holder of health insurances stock.
    America is the only developed country in the world that does not have a universal health care. The health care in USA is the most expensive in the world, but ranks #37. If you don't consider health care is a moral issue (human right or a privilege?), would you mind to realize that system is broken and finally going to bankrupt the country.
  • texasconservative
    In "Never Never Land", (Obimbicile-land) everybody has enough to eat, and no one ever gets sick, and everyone has enough money to buy everything they want...don't they?!!
    The problem, Mr. Name is, we live in the world of REALITY, where none of that exists! The best we can do is, do the best we can for those who CONTRIBUTE, by working, and paying for themselves (personal-responsibility).
    Universal Health Care has to be paid by someone (guess who) ? According to the U.S. Treasury, in 2007 the U.S. had a NEGATIVE-OBLIGATION of $59 TRILLION....TRILLION!! That's more than the ENTIRE WORLD COMBINED!! By the end of 2008 that NEGATIVE-OBLIGATION, will reach $65 TRILLION....that's...$65 TRILLION!!! For all intense and purpose, we're in BANKRUPTCY...and this IDIOT-PRESIDENT, and some in Congress want to push us farther into a debt by passing another entitlement that will cost $TRILLIONS, and adding that bill to a bill we CANNOT-SUSTAIN?!!
    This isn't rocket-science Mr. Name, it's just dollars & sense!!
  • texasconservative
    Again your wrong! Doesn't it embarrass you to assume, and then be made to look like a fool?!!
    My kids went to private Christian-schools so they would receive an education. It's obvious, you DIDN'T!!
  • ANDY
    1. Name was being sarcastic about you putting your children through public schools. 2. You misspelled sheep 3. The bankruptcy is due to deficit spending from the previous administration.
  • Craig_Sipple1
    Your "socialised school system" theory doesn't hold water, its only you guys in America that are having trouble. We in Europe are doing just fine, indeed the highest ranking countries in the world regarding education are ALL socialised.

    My kid goes to school to learn literacy, mathamatics, science, engineering... I am not interested in classes on the magic invisible man who lives in the sky, I bet you that is one of the major contributing factors of why American kids are so clueless.

    Do me a favour old chap, use your superior education and try and find the US on these tables. All I can see are countries who opporate "socialised education" programmes.

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1571445/...

    Maybe you could ask Jeebus for help,

  • texasconservative
    Our public education system, k-12, is a joke. There are many reasons why one of the best public school systems in the world has degenerated into a baby-sitting service. It don't take much research to know that the Liberal/Conservative agenda for the las 30 years has been to cater to the business interests who wanted to import legal/illegal immigrant workers to give them higher profit margins at the cost of lost jobs for American citizens. The vast majority of imported legal/illegals being poorly educated. They have overwhelmed our education system and forced our children to stagnate while the schools tried to bring the illegal/legal immigrant children up to par. They have failed, miserably, and our children have had to suffer for it. Instead of maintain the high level of achievement required, they have lowered the requirement to graduate, year after year, until we now have students who can't read their own diplomas!
    This idiocy has been going on so long, the teachers now teaching, are products of that system, so you can imagine the level of educational standards now in place. It's for that reason many people are opting out of the public school system in favor of private schools or home-schooling. There are so many kids being home-schooled in CA. that the public school administrators are trying to get home-schooling outlawed, even thought the home-schooled children consistently have far higher test scores than children in public school.
  • ANDY
    Hi, I immigrated here at the age of 8. I am currently a 4.0 student at an University. Its been my experience from working with future teachers that the reason our education system is lacking is that many of these would-be teachers have a C's get degrees mentality. They do the bare minimum because they really just want 3 months of vacation. In turn some parents encourage their children to get good grades by paying them. The no child left behind act leaves little room for innovative teaching techniques and forces teachers to practically teach students what is necessary for them to pass a test. Add these to the American mentality that everyone has a right to an education and you have your public education system. I agree that everyone has a right to an education. But, children who are brought up with this mentality often fail to see that it really is a privilege that will escape them at any moment. Believe me my parents never let me forget that they didn't have that privilege: my father was forced into manual labor when he was 8 years old to help support his family and my mother was never allowed to go to school because she was a girl. I never really understood this until know that I have to work two jobs to pay for my education.
  • Craig_Sipple1
    There is a clear problem, but as the above tables show it has nothing to do with socialism. Not everything bad is down to socialism you know.

    I think your education woes could have something to do with your brat culture, that and under funding on a crippling scale. If you can pay extra for your own kids, wouldn't society benifit from everyone collectively paying extra for all kids? after all you have to live with these people.
  • texasconservative
    Yes, culture plays in big role in education in the U.S. The amount of legal, and especially illegal aliens that flooded our school systems have brought their culture with them, and in many instances, it's in direct conflict with the estblished culture of this country.
  • liberalconservative
    texasconservative not popular support? 65% of Americans want reform isn't that enough or are you still using the poll done by a health care provider.
  • texasconservative
    Latest Rassmussen poll says, 56% of Americans are against the health care bill.
    59% of seniors are against the bill.

    Where did you get the 65% number?
  • texasconservative
    Still waiting......
  • Craig_Sipple1
    NYT/CBS Poll and accepted by everyone on the right and the left:

    http://senateagenda.wordpress.com/2009/09/25/pu...

    As for Rassmunssen, that organisations right-wing bias has made it a laughing stock among major pollsters. Tells you what you want to hear so I guess its all right that its questions are too often squeed too the right or that its questions are robo-called into right wing neighborhoods.

    --------------------------------

    Genuine Rassmussen question (really, I am not kidding!):

    "Suppose that Democrats agreed on a health care reform bill that is opposed by all Republicans in Congress. Should the Democrats pass that bill or should they change the bill to win support from a reasonable number of Republicans?"

    "reasonable"... really??.... what a complete joke!
  • texasconservative
    NO, the NYT/CBS poll is not excepted by all on both sides! Where the hell did you come up with that little bit of nonsense?! NO...really...where!

    1) pollingreport.com = 52% OPPOSE HEALTH CARE BILL.
    2) lifenews.com = 53% " " "
    3) NBC poll. = 53% " " "
    4) quinnipiac poll. = 55% " " "
    5) assoc.press poll. = 52% " " "

    Even the White-House under Bill Clinton discounted the NYT/CBS polls because they were so biased!
  • texasconservative
    The health care bill in it's present form should be scraped, as polls indicate. It's not about what Congress wants, it's about what "we the people", want!! It's obvious to everyone that health care reforms are needed but, those reforms need not bankrupt this country. And more importantly, the government should not be involved other than in tort-reform, removing inter-state regulations that stifle national competition.
    Regulation of insurance companies should be at the state level where they can be more closely monitored and regulated.
  • Craig_Sipple1
    its about what "we the people", want?..... yeh, right.

    Keep dreaming.
  • texasconservative
    I'm afraid you my be right. This government has done it's level best to exclude the people, and they are succeeding at an alarming rate. But, on the other side I see a growing number of people so pissed off they are willing to take whatever measures it will take to take back the government. That's why we are seeing a new assault on the 2nd Amendment.
  • Craig_Sipple1
    Good luck with that, I have seen busier funerals than those tea parties. And even if you were to mobilise Murdoch would just erase any sign from it from the media. America is to big and communities too atomised for resistence.

    There could be beginnings of this now, but you and I would never hear about it. Severel thousands of miles may seperate us but we envision the world through the same window, a window of "Dancing With The Stars" , "The X Factor" and scripted news.... but your revolution will not be televised.

  • texasconservative
    Is the issue, about a GOP health care bill, or is the issue about the very bad Democratic health care bill? Are Rep.Grayson's remarks germane, or are they intended to deflect criticism of the bill the Democrats are trying to get passed without popular support?
  • docwillis
    "Is the issue, about a GOP health care bill, or is the issue about the very bad Democratic health care bill? Are Rep.Grayson's remarks germane, or are they intended to deflect criticism of the bill the Democrats are trying to get passed without popular support?"

    Was there a gop health care bill? All I heard were "death panels" and "government wants to kill your grandma" talk from the right.
  • texasconservative
    Shouldn't this be a bi-partisan effort to address the health care issues that need attention? Destroying an entire health care system seems foolish when 85% of the population that is insured is saying fix only what is broken and leave the rest alone.
    This isn't about health care, it about this government trying to impose even more power over our private lives. Instead of growing this intrusive government we should be demanding they do what only the Constitution allows them to do.
    You'd have to be completely naive to think this government cares about your health care! This is about forcing us into a socialistic system of government.
  • docwillis
    "Shouldn't this be a bi-partisan effort to address the health care issues that need attention?"

    Absolutely! Some from the Republican party mentioned tax cuts, which is an option I suppose. But a lot of it is being drowned out by "death panels" and "government wants to kill your grandma" talk which doesn't sound bi-partisan to me.

    "Destroying an entire health care system seems foolish when 85% of the population that is insured is saying fix only what is broken and leave the rest alone."

    Another scare phrase from the right - it's the INSURANCE MONOPOLY and their abuse (obscene profits and the ever expanding list of denying people with pre-existing conditions) that needs to be fixed. A public option would do that.

    "This isn't about health care, it about this government trying to impose even more power over our private lives."

    Two words, Tex: Patriot Act. The silence from the right was deafening...

    "Instead of growing this intrusive government we should be demanding they do what only the Constitution allows them to do."

    ALL U.S. citizens should have access to health care, period.

    "You'd have to be completely naive to think this government cares about your health care!"

    And you'd have to be completely naive to think the insurance companies are going to fix this debacle by themselves.

    "This is about forcing us into a socialistic system of government."

    One question, Tex. Do your parents have social security or Medicare? Very socialistic programs, I admit. And both WORK!
  • texasconservative
    The "death panel", was in the initial draft of the health care bill but, as I understand it, it has been removed. I'm not so sure, an end of life panel-like discussion of your options is a bad thing? As long as the final binding decision remains with you.

    The Patriot Act, was rushed through Congress with the use of strong-arm, and scare tactics. Bush got the bill passed with little discussion. The same tactics Obama is using to get his health care bill passed. Only this time, enough people stood up and said, wait a minute, let's take a good look at this problem before open the door on boondoggle we may never be able to close. There may be better ways of fixing this problem than handing over 1/6 of our private-economy to the government. A government that has demonstrated over and over again they cant' efficiently run anything.

    Your right, the insurance co. will not, on their own, correct their dismal practices. This is where the government steps in and passes regulations stopping that trash.
    Insurance co. were actually on board with Obama until they found out Obama was going to allow people to opt-out of buying insurance by paying a ridiculously small fine, and allow them to buy insurance only when they need it?

    Medicare and Medicaid, two socialist health care programs that are nearing bankruptcy. Medicaid is destroying state budgets, and that's just covering children! Medicare is rife with corruption the estimates of theft is between $50 and $150 Billion annually! Doctors are opting out of the Medicare program because they are being paid below the national standard.
    Medicare and Medicaid are NOT working!!

    The answer is the free-market. Remove the regulations stopping inter-state competition, tort reform, and promote transparency in costs, and billing. The governments job should be that of a referee, not a player.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Subscribe to the Brave New Films blog